Эдзард Эрнст

"Trick or Treatment? Alternative Medicine on Trial. Summary"

Chapter 1: The World of Alternative Medicine

The book provides an introduction to the realm of alternative medicine and its growing popularity. It discusses a wide range of treatments and therapies, including acupuncture and homeopathy, which are often sought as alternatives to conventional medicine. This chapter emphasizes the importance of subjecting these alternative treatments to scientific research to assess their effectiveness.

Chapter 2: Exploring the Origins of Alternative Therapies

A deep dive into the origins and practices of alternative therapies like acupuncture and homeopathy. It offers historical context for these treatments and explains their fundamental principles. The chapter underscores the significance of conducting rigorous scientific tests to establish the credibility and effectiveness of these therapies.

Chapter 3: The Principles of Alternative Medicine

Principles and beliefs that underpin many alternative therapies. The authors discuss the concepts of vitalism, which involves an unproven life force, and the body's innate ability to heal itself. They explain how these principles often form the basis for various alternative treatments, despite a lack of scientific evidence to support them. The chapter stresses the importance of examining these core principles critically.

Chapter 4: The Troubled Birth of Homeopathy

Homeopathy, a widely known alternative therapy. The authors explore the history of homeopathy, beginning with its founder, Samuel Hahnemann. They discuss the principles of homeopathy, including the "law of similars" and the "law of infinitesimals," which involve using highly diluted substances. The chapter delves into the controversy surrounding homeopathy's efficacy and the problems with clinical trials in this field. It highlights the challenges of reconciling homeopathy's principles with modern scientific understanding.

Chapter 5: Chiropractic - a Spine-Chilling Story

The practice of chiropractic. The authors discuss the history of chiropractic care, which is centered on the belief that many diseases are due to spinal misalignments that can be corrected by manual adjustments. However, they emphasize the lack of scientific evidence to support this belief. The chapter also explores the risks associated with chiropractic treatments, particularly spinal manipulation. It highlights the ongoing debate about the safety and effectiveness of this alternative therapy.

Chapter 6: A Fairy Tale from the Amazon

The alternative therapy Ayurveda, a traditional Indian system of medicine. The authors delve into the origins and principles of Ayurveda, which involve balancing the body's doshas(vital energies) to maintain health. The chapter discusses the lack of rigorous scientific research supporting Ayurvedic treatments and the potential risks of herbal remedies. It also highlights the issue of heavy metal contamination in Ayurvedic medicines and the need for regulation in this field.

Chapter 7: Herbal Medicine - the Good, the

Bad, and the Ugly

The world of herbal medicine, which has a long history of use. The authors discuss how some herbs have been effective in treating certain conditions and have formed the basis for modern drugs. However, they emphasize that the majority of herbal remedies lack scientific evidence to prove their safety and efficacy. The chapter also addresses the risks associated with herbal medicines, including contamination and dosage issues. It highlights the need for stringent regulations in the herbal medicine industry.

Chapter 8: Unnatural Therapies - Traditional Chinese Medicine

Traditional Chinese Medicine(TCM), which includes acupuncture, herbal medicine, and other therapies. The authors discuss the history and principles of TCM, emphasizing the concept of Qi(energy flow) and the use of acupuncture needles to correct imbalances. They examine the scientific evidence for acupuncture and herbal treatments, finding that the outcomes are often inconsistent or lacking. The chapter also raises concerns about the potential risks and side effects of acupuncture and TCM remedies. It underscores the importance of rigorous scientific testing for these therapies.

Chapter 9: Manipulating the Spine - Chiropractic and Osteopathy

Chiropractic and osteopathy, two alternative therapies that primarily involve spinal manipulation. The authors delve into the history of these practices and examine their theories and treatment methods. They also evaluate the scientific evidence behind chiropractic and osteopathy, particularly in the context of treating back pain. While spinal manipulation can provide relief for some patients, the chapter highlights the risks involved, such as stroke following neck manipulation. It emphasizes the importance of a rigorous scientific approach to assess these therapies.

Chapter 10: Wider Horizons - Traditional Medicine, Homeopathy, and Conclusion

Various alternative therapies, including traditional medicine systems, homeopathy, and some of the broader issues surrounding alternative medicine. The authors discuss Ayurveda, Traditional Chinese Medicine, and other traditional systems, assessing their efficacy. They also tackle the controversial topic of homeopathy, examining its fundamental principles and the lack of scientific evidence to support its claims.